[Assessment 1134] Re: Intensity of Instruction and funding of adult ESLprograms

Share: Share on LinkedIn! Print page! More options

Archived Content Disclaimer

This page contains archived content from a LINCS email discussion list that closed in 2012. This content is not updated as part of LINCS’ ongoing website maintenance, and hyperlinks may be broken.

Forrest Chisman forrest at crosslink.net
Wed Feb 6 11:33:37 EST 2008


That's too bad about your experiences with managed enrollment. Some of the
colleges we studied think they "beat this rap" by creating very large
managed enrollment classes to allow for attrition. (For them, managed
enrollment meant that if students didn't attend on a regular basis, they
were dropped from the program.) They figured that what they lost in head
counts, they made up for in contact hours. But we also heard stories like
yours. I'm beginning to believe that "managed enrollment" works best as one
of several "tracks" -- if a program is large enough to have "tracks" -- a
track for the motivated. Some programs believe that it is by itself
"motivational" -- in that it encourages students to make more of a

What do the rest of you think?


-----Original Message-----
From: assessment-bounces at nifl.gov [mailto:assessment-bounces at nifl.gov] On
Behalf Of Schneider, Jim
Sent: Tuesday, February 05, 2008 11:30 PM
To: Jodi Crandall; The Assessment Discussion List
Subject: [Assessment 1126] Re: Intensity of Instruction and funding of adult

At our cc based adult learning center we do not charge any fees for

We have dabbled with the managed enrollment, however our institution is
driven by enrollment and contact hours so that we simply cannot afford to
operate in a managed enrollment fashion. I do believe that it is better for
the teachers and students. Unfortunately, operating in a strict fashion, our
enrollment took close to a 50% reduction. Still, recognizing the value of
the concept, the past two years we have attempted a semi-managed enrollment.
In the fall we have a 3 week enrollment period and then hold classes with no
additional students for 5 weeks. Then an additional 3 week open enrollment
followed by no new students for 5 weeks. Ideally, we would operate in this
fashion year round providing some sense of continuity for the instructors
and learners. Unfortunately, student attendance waxes and wanes due to
employment, weather, transportation, etc. and in each year we attempted this
we held to it through the second 5 weeks and then abandon it for the
remainder of the year because student attendance/enrollment declined to the
point that we had to enroll any learner whenever they were interested to
meet our enrollment goals.

The bulk of our english learners enroll in the three levels of morning
classes which meet Monday through Thursday from 8:30 until 11 a.m.. Our
evening program has varied from 2-3 levels. Evening classes meet Monday and
Wednesday from 6 to 8 p.m.. Both morning and evening classes are offered for
approximately 38 weeks through the fall and spring semesters.

These offerings are "how we have always done it" and are somewhat bound by
the available funds.

Jim, "I like the sound of eloquent" Schneider

From: assessment-bounces at nifl.gov on behalf of JoAnn (Jodi) Crandall
Sent: Tue 2/5/2008 3:30 PM
To: Assessment at nifl.gov
Subject: [Assessment 1116] Intensity of Instruction and funding of adult

Hi, everyone. It has been interesting reading the postings today and want
to respond to some of them now. I just learned from Forrest that his
Internet Service Provider is down, but he expects to be back on line either
tonight or tomorrow. He'll add his comments later.

In the meantime, let me respond to a couple of themes that have emerged in
the discussion.

Jackie asked what we meant by "intensity of instruction" and Marie provided
a definition from an excellent publication from the Center for Applied
Linguistics which analyzes the effects of instructional hours and intensity
of instruction on NRS level gains in listening and speaking.

In our study, we define "intensity of instruction" as the number of hours
per week and differentiate it from "duration" which is the total number of
hours for the program.
We think both intensity and duration are important. It is important to have
enough hours per week of instruction, but also important that there be
enough weeks. Programs in the 5 community colleges we studied varied from 3
to 20 hours per week of instruction, with 10 hours/week considered
"semi-intensive" and 20 hours/week as "intensive" instruction.

As Jim so eloquently put it, there are some basic reasons why programs might
not offer as many hours of instruction per week as they want to, with
funding being at the root of many of the reasons.

Forrest and I would be interested in knowing how many hours per week your
various programs meet (and for how many weeks) and how you determined that
schedule. Have you tried more intense programs for shorter periods of time?
What has been the impact on attendance?

Have any of you provided adult ESL/ESOL programs that charge a fee? We were
surprised to learn of such a program at Bunker Hill Community College. They
provide free adult ESOL and also a fee-based program in an attempt to
accommodate more learners. They found that at least some learners were able
to pay the fee and thus they were able to serve more learners.

We'd also like to know if your programs are open-entry/open-exit, with
learners coming to class when they can and sometimes leaving for several
classes before they return, or if you have tried some kind of "managed
enrollment" with attendance expectations of those who are enrolled in your
classes. Several community colleges have experimented with this approach
and have found it effective. I know that Forrest will have more to say
about this.

I have to go teach, but when I return, I'd like to talk a bit about issues
surrounding literacy and prior education.

Jodi Crandall

National Institute for Literacy
Assessment mailing list
Assessment at nifl.gov
To unsubscribe or change your subscription settings, please go to
Email delivered to jschneider at eicc.edu