[Technology 952] Re: Subject: RE: handhelds day 2

Share: Share on LinkedIn! Print page! More options

Archived Content Disclaimer

This page contains archived content from a LINCS email discussion list that closed in 2012. This content is not updated as part of LINCS’ ongoing website maintenance, and hyperlinks may be broken.

Mike Moyle Mike.Moyle at prin.edu
Thu Apr 19 15:54:30 EDT 2007

My Palm stopped syncing with my tablet computer so I switched to an HP
with a Windows platform. I'm not sure how much education software is
available for this PDA platform.

-----Original Message-----
From: technology-bounces at nifl.gov [mailto:technology-bounces at nifl.gov]
On Behalf Of Denis Anson
Sent: Thursday, April 19, 2007 2:48 PM
To: The Technology and Literacy Discussion List
Subject: [Technology 951] Re: Subject: RE: handhelds day 2

I've also gone through a number of Palm devices. My experience is that
they have a life expectancy of about two years, and then you need a new

I also read a rumor that Dell may buy Palm, so your Palm will be a Dell,
or something like that. I would buy a smart phone today if they didn't
have those silly little keyboards using up the interface. My fingers
cover about half a dozen buttons, and I don't think I could even dial
one, much less type on it. For note taking on my Palm, I use a
universal, full sized keyboard, which allows full speed typing.

Denis Anson

McNutt Jr, William R wrote:


> I just had an experience I thought I would share with ya'll. Recently,

> my beloved Dell Axim X51 handheld had a stroke, and I had to replace

> it. I ordered a new one from dell.com and got a better screen and more

> memory in the new model. Adding the network capability that I use, it

> came to slightly more than $500.00. My wife bought a Treo smartphone

> that does just about everything my Axim does for less.


> Two weeks later, announced that they were dead-ending the Axim line. I

> can no longer find my brand-new handheld on the dell web site.

> Subsequent looking around reveals that the conventional wisdom among

> the technorati is that handheld computers have had their day in the

> sun. The smart money is betting on the smartphone, like the Blackjack

> and the Treo replacing the handheld for most functions.


> Bill McNutt


> ----------------------------------------------------------------------

> --


> *From:* technology-bounces at nifl.gov

> [mailto:technology-bounces at nifl.gov] *On Behalf Of *Mariann Fedele

> *Sent:* Thursday, April 19, 2007 2:26 PM

> *To:* The Technology and Literacy Discussion List

> *Subject:* [Technology 945] Subject: RE: handhelds day 2


> *The following question is submitted on behalf of Mike Moyle:*


> Marilyn,


> Thank you for sharing with us. Our fifth grade has used Palms for

> several years. They are used primarily for writing but also for math

> facts, organizing assignments, drawing with Sketchy, and understanding

> tessellations. The teachers are about to use them with paam.goknow.com

> Internet so the student can sync with that site when their homework is

> done, and the teacher can instantly see it.


> Our school is considering 1-to-1 technology with tablet laptop

> computers for grades 7-12. The teachers were each given a tablet and

> four days of training this summer.


> I'm trying to decide whether handhelds or tablets are the better way

> to go for Lower School. You've identified the cost factor. If that is

> the primary driving force, the handhelds probably are the best bet. I

> do worry, though, about not having access to the connectivity with the

> web and the ability to create through programs like PowerPoint, Movie

> Maker, etc. It seems that the handhelds have a very narrow focus of

> abilities compared to a laptop or tablet. I don't know, however, if

> this is a completely accurate view. I'd love to hear more about that.


> I was interested to read about your project with creating governments.

> I keep thinking that the technology is only a tool, and it's extremely

> important to make sure we are using it in a way that is helping

> students think at higher levels, make connections, and be creative.


> Mike Moyle

> Lower School Director

> The Principia


> -----Original Message-----

> From: technology-bounces at nifl.gov [mailto:technology-bounces at nifl.gov]

> On Behalf Of Marilyn Williams

> Sent: Wednesday, April 18, 2007 9:19 AM

> To: technology at nifl.gov

> Subject: [Technology 936] handhelds day 2


> Hi all,

> Thanks again for participating in the discussion today. Please send me

> any comments or questions as I'd love to establish a dialogue with



> As it closer to school starting and despite two full days of training,

> I was still feeling apprehensive about starting the Palm project.

> Nonetheless, students were back at school a week later and I had to be

> ready to go.

> Our first day, I introduced the fact that we had the opportunity to

> use the handhelds and explained that everyone would need to take home

> the permission form and have it back before we would begin to use the


> I thought this would give me a week or so of breathing room!

> Of course, they all came back the next day! So, taking a deep breath,

> we jumped in.

> Those first few days were a little chaotic! I did have some basic

> plans developed but, for the most part, we played. We experimented

> with different functions and sent messages to one another. We also

> saved our work and set up categories (or files).


> One of the most helpful pieces of equipment I used was a FlexCam. This

> is a camera that has a flexible neck that can be bent to show whatever

> the teacher is working on. They are often used in science classes so

> all the students can watch a teacher do a dissection or other

> experiment.

> This allowed me to demonstrate which buttons or icons to tap and how

> and where to enter information on a screen. It really was (and still

> is) invaluable.


> Our first lessons were basic how to enter information. We played with

> writing Graffiti, using the built in keyboard as well as the external

> keyboard. A fun game to use when learning Graffiti is called Giraffe.


> As we all became more proficient, I started using the Palms in 'real'

> lessons. At first, it was a stretch to think of how I would use them

> but as they became part of my repertoire, it was second nature. One of

> the earlier projects we did was on government. I divided students into

> groups and their task was to create a society. Each group had a set of

> categories to address such as school, laws, justice, economy etc. Each

> student worked on their section then everyone beamed their portion to

> each other so the entire group had everyone's work. This was a great

> way to keep them organized and if anyone lost their work, they could

> easily retrieve it.


> Daily, we used our Palms for silent reading responses as well as a

> unit on word parts. We kept a list and definitions and examples of

> literary terms and devices. We wrote poetry which worked great as I

> beamed everyone a template and instructions and then they could work

> independently.

> I know I keep mentioning beaming and I should perhaps explain this

> function. This allows a person to just point their Palm at another

> Palm, tap 'Beam' and the data is transferred from one to another.

> After a bit of practice we got so we could beam a piece of data to

> everyone in the class in the same amount of time it would take to pass

out papers.

> I would beam to one student, they would beam to another while I got

> someone else started etc.


> It was important for us to organize the Palms in a way that they were

> easily accessible so I set up a series of small drawers which

> contained each person's Palm and keyboard. Students were responsible

> to make sure their Palm was charged and available and, for the most

> part, this worked well. If someone forgot theirs at home, they ended

> up having to use paper and pencil and that was usually enough

> deterrent that it wasn't left at home again.


> The biggest advantage of Palms, for me, was the way it leveled the

> playing field, so to speak, for all my students. I had taught some of

> these students since sixth grade in a resource (pull

> out) block and had never been able to get them interested in writing.

> Now that they had this tool and the example of their peers, they

> became much more engaged and I was so pleased with the progress they


> They felt much more positive about themselves as learners as well.


> Fortunately, we had a class set of Palms so everyone had access. In a

> setting without a class set, I might establish a 'Palm learning


> as part of a rotation. At that center, I'd probably have assignments

> listed and have students work in a more individual way. It certainly

> is more difficult to incorporate any kind of technology when students

> have to share.


> So far, we've lost only 1 handheld over 3 years!


> Marilyn Williams

> 6th Grade Language Arts/Social Studies Kennedy Middle School Eugene,

> OR

> ----------------------------------------------------

> National Institute for Literacy

> Technology and Literacy mailing list

> Technology at nifl.gov

> To unsubscribe or change your subscription settings, please go to

> http://www.nifl.gov/mailman/l

> <http://www.nifl.gov/mailman/listinfo/technology>


> Mariann Fedele


> Associate Director,


> NYC Regional Adult Education Network


> Literacy Assistance Center


> Moderator,

> NIFL Technology and Literacy Discussion List

> 32 Broadway 10th Floor

> New York, New York 10004

> 212-803-3325

> mariannf at lacnyc.org <mailto:mariannf at lacnyc.org> www.lacnyc.org

> <http://www.lacnyc.org>


> ----------------------------------------------------------------------

> --


> ----------------------------------------------------

> National Institute for Literacy

> Technology and Literacy mailing list

> Technology at nifl.gov

> To unsubscribe or change your subscription settings, please go to

> http://www.nifl.gov/mailman/listinfo/technology

National Institute for Literacy
Technology and Literacy mailing list
Technology at nifl.gov
To unsubscribe or change your subscription settings, please go to